Introduction to the Professions
Biology, Chemistry, and Physics 100
lecture notes for Thursday - Tuesday, 31 August - 4 September 2006
The Tools of Science
Tools in science fall in these categories:
This list is not intended to cover absolutely all the tools one brings
to bear on solving scientific problems; you may wish to add your own.
-
The Experimental Method
We discussed this method
last lecture.
form an hypothesis |
devise an experiment |
perform and analyze experiment |
interpret results of experiment |
refine hypothesis, devise further experiments |
develop theories, synthesizing several results |
In what sense is the experimental method a tool?
This entire approach to understanding nature is a way
of operating;
it channels our thoughts in particular directions.
When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
-
Apparatus
Excludes experimental samples themselves:
the latter are the elements of nature that we are studying,
not the equipment.
General-purpose vs. special-purpose apparatus:
-
General-purpose apparatus provide for numerous experiments.
-
Special-purpose apparatus provides for one or a few experiments.
Example from protein crystallography:
-
General-purpose: X-ray generator, monochromator, goniostat, detector
-
Special-purpose: laser for initiating chemical change; high-pressure cell.
Must we understand the internals of our apparatus in order to use
it?
Not necessarily, but it helps, especially with special-purpose equipment.
Sociological difference between physicists and biologists:
-
physicists tend to be "at home" with their apparatus, having designed it
themselves;
-
biologists tend to treat their apparatus as black boxes.
-
chemists are intermediate between these extremes.
-
Mathematics
The language of science, as we said last lecture.
Almost any scientific endeavor uses arithmetic and statistics.
Many use much more sophisticated branches of mathematics--
Fourier analysis, group theory, partial differential
equations, fractals, . . .
Statistics: multiple observations, significance levels
provides tool to assess correlations among variables.
Recurrent danger: biasing the results toward the model:
Example from protein crystallography: structure refinement
It can take some very sophisticated tools to escape this problem!
-
Computers
We limped along without them until fifty years ago.
[Speed, Flexibility](palmtop,2000) > [Speed, Flexibility](mainframe,1966)
Survey of scientific applications, based on history:
repetitive high-speed arithmetic |
FORmula TRANslation |
instrument control |
word processing |
record-keeping ("electronic notebooks") |
graphics: representation and analysis |
simulation (in silico experiments) |
algorithmic algebra (Mathematica, etc.) |
communications |
access to information repositories (see below) |
Dangers of using computers in science
-
they can make it easier to get results without understanding
-
can invest bogus ideas with undeserved air of authority
-
Information Repositories
If I had written this lecture seven yours ago I would have headed this
"libraries".
Now: libraries, Internet, publicly available databases
How to make the most of these?
-
Gee-whiz factor goes up the more modern the repository is.
-
It takes some practice to learn how to ask the right questions.
-
Some of the Websites help you do that, though.
-
Intuition
This is usually developed from experience: previous similar phenomena;
patterns
-
Peer Interactions
Simple: face-to-face conversations, phone calls, e-mail
More organized: bulletin boards, Web, previewing manuscripts,
scientific meetings, scientific societies
true peer review of manuscripts and proposals
How do these help the science you're doing?
generates new ideas |
pokes holes in your bad ideas |
puts your experiments in a wider context |
helps you find procedural tricks |
source of free or near-free software, equipment, etc. |
starts or maintains funding |