Introduction to the Professions
Biology, Chemistry, and Physics 100
lecture notes for Thursday - Tuesday, 31 August - 4 September 2006

The Tools of Science

Tools in science fall in these categories:
The Experimental Method    Apparatus    Mathematics    Computers
Information Repositories    Intuition    Peer Interactions

This list is not intended to cover absolutely all the tools one brings to bear on solving scientific problems; you may wish to add your own.

  1. The Experimental Method
    We discussed this method last lecture.
  2. form an hypothesis    devise an experiment
    perform and analyze experiment    interpret results of experiment
    refine hypothesis, devise further experiments    develop theories, synthesizing several results

    In what sense is the experimental method a tool?
       This entire approach to understanding nature is a way of operating;
    it channels our thoughts in particular directions.
      When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.

  3. Apparatus
  4. Excludes experimental samples themselves:
      the latter are the elements of nature that we are studying, not the equipment.
    General-purpose vs. special-purpose apparatus:

    Example from protein crystallography:

    Must we understand the internals of our apparatus in order to use it?
    Not necessarily, but it helps, especially with special-purpose equipment.
    Sociological difference between physicists and biologists:

    1. physicists tend to be "at home" with their apparatus, having designed it themselves;
    2. biologists tend to treat their apparatus as black boxes.
    3. chemists are intermediate between these extremes.

  5. Mathematics
  6. The language of science, as we said last lecture.
    Almost any scientific endeavor uses arithmetic and statistics.
    Many use much more sophisticated branches of mathematics--
        Fourier analysis, group theory, partial differential equations, fractals, . . .
    Statistics: multiple observations, significance levels
       provides tool to assess correlations among variables.
    Recurrent danger: biasing the results toward the model:
      Example from protein crystallography: structure refinement
    It can take some very sophisticated tools to escape this problem!
     
  7. Computers
  8. We limped along without them until fifty years ago.
    [Speed, Flexibility](palmtop,2000) > [Speed, Flexibility](mainframe,1966)

    Survey of scientific applications, based on history:
    repetitive high-speed arithmetic FORmula TRANslation
    instrument control word processing
    record-keeping ("electronic notebooks") graphics: representation and analysis
    simulation (in silico experiments) algorithmic algebra (Mathematica, etc.)
    communications access to information repositories (see below)

    Dangers of using computers in science

  9. Information Repositories
  10. If I had written this lecture seven yours ago I would have headed this "libraries".
    Now: libraries, Internet, publicly available databases
    How to make the most of these?
  11. Intuition
  12. This is usually developed from experience: previous similar phenomena; patterns
     
  13. Peer Interactions
  14. Simple: face-to-face conversations, phone calls, e-mail
    More organized: bulletin boards, Web, previewing manuscripts,
       scientific meetings, scientific societies
    true peer review of manuscripts and proposals
    How do these help the science you're doing?
    generates new ideas   pokes holes in your bad ideas
    puts your experiments in a wider context   helps you find procedural tricks
    source of free or near-free software, equipment, etc. starts or maintains funding